At the start of Queen Victoria’s long reign,
the Gothic Revival in Britain was gathering momentum, with Barry and Pugin
showing the way as their Houses of Parliament arose beside the Thames at the
very heart of the British Empire. This was a time when architects made it
their business to journey to the great cathedrals, the monasteries, the
parish churches, the castles and the manor houses of the Middle Ages and to
record them in measured drawings and freehand sketches. With inexpensive
architectural periodicals providing professionals with a wealth of
up-to-the-minute information, dedicated architects were able to ac— quire a
wealth of knowledge about medieval buildings. It is thus not surprising that
a high degree of scholarship is evident in the design of many Victorian
buildings which adopted a Gothic style.
But there were good reasons why the designers of many buildings in the
Gothic idiom were not especially concerned with archaeological correctness.
Most nineteenth-century buildings had requirements vastly different from
those of the Middle Ages; some, like railway stations, had no precedent.
Many architects saw ‘modern Gothic’ as a style of the present, not the past.
And there were those who lacked the expertise, and perhaps the desire, to
take a scholarly approach to the re-use of elements of medieval
architecture.
The writings of Ruskin, full of moral fervour and glowing descriptions of
that most ‘impure’ of styles, Venetian Gothic, also tended to lead
architects away from a drily academic regurgitation of medieval details to
experiment with picturesque silhouettes and polychromatic surfaces. The
rich, complex rhythms and textures of William Pitt’s late nineteenth-century
commercial façades which line the city streets of Melbourne show how
exuberantly Free Gothic designers departed from academic correctness as they
expressed something of the euphoria generated by the city’s financiers in
the years before the crash of the early 1890s.
In Australia, Victorian Free Gothic was a flexible and versatile idiom.
While the established Protestant Church tended to favour Academic Gothic,
the nonconformist denominations often chose Free Gothic. But the style was
certainly not confined to churches and buildings with religious
associations. At its best, it was used to create memorable buildings of
vigorous and original design. Richard Roach Jewell’s Town Hall in Perth and
John Young’s Abbey in Annandale, Sydney, are among that special breed of
Free Gothic landmark buildings which once seen are not easily forgotten.
Examples
Oldefleet Building, Collins Street, Melbourne, Vic. William Pitt, architect,
1889-90. A flamboyant façade incorporating excellent brick, tile and cement
work.
Great Synagogue, Elizabeth Street, Sydney. NSW, Thomas Rowe, architect,
completed 1878. A composite building of Romanesque, Gothic and Byzantine
motifs.
Perth Town Hall. Completed 1870
Former Metropolitan Gas Company Buildings;
Flinders Street, Melbourne. Completed 1892; Venetian Gothic applied to a
tall building